Homemade Cookie Butter Spread Recipe

If you’ve ever wished you could capture the magic of those dreamy cookie butter jars right in your own kitchen, I have good news. This Homemade Cookie Butter Spread Recipe is exactly what you need—creamy, spiced, and incredibly easy to whip up. You’ll find that making it yourself not only saves you money but also lets you tweak the flavor just how you like it. Trust me, once you try this, store-bought just won’t compare.

this …

Ingredients You’ll Need

Each ingredient in this Homemade Cookie Butter Spread Recipe plays a key role in balancing flavor and texture. Simple pantry staples come together beautifully to recreate that beloved cookie butter taste, and I’ll share how to pick the best ones.

• Gingersnap cookies: These are the star of the show, bringing that classic spiced cookie flavor; fresh, crispy ones blend best.
• Whole milk: Adds creaminess and helps smooth out the spread; if your cookies are dry, a splash more milk might be needed.
• Unsalted butter: Enriches the spread giving it a lovely silky finish, and unsalted lets you control the saltiness.
• Vanilla extract: A little vanilla adds warmth and rounds out the cookie spices perfectly.
• Ground cinnamon: For that cozy spice kick that enhances the ginger and sweetness.
• Powdered sugar: Sweetens without grittiness, essential for that smooth texture.
• Fine sea salt: Just a pinch to balance sweetness and deepen flavors.

Variations

I love that this Homemade Cookie Butter Spread Recipe invites personalization – it’s one of the best things about making it yourself! Feel free to mix and match spices or even change up the cookie base for something new.

• Use different cookies: I once tried it with speculoos cookies for a nuttier twist, and it was fantastic.
• Add nut butters: A spoonful of almond or peanut butter can deepen flavor and add richness.
• Adjust sweetness: Depending on your cookies, you might want to add more or less powdered sugar—taste as you go.
• Spice it up: Experiment with a pinch of nutmeg or cardamom to create unique holiday versions.

How to Make Homemade Cookie Butter Spread Recipe

Step 1: Prep Your Cookies

Start by breaking your gingersnap cookies into chunks. This helps the blender or food processor do its magic quickly and evenly. If your cookies are super crunchy, they’ll blend up smoothly with no problem, but if they’re a bit stale, no worries—you might just want to add a touch more milk to keep things creamy.

Step 2: Blend Everything Together

Pop the cookie pieces, whole milk, unsalted butter, vanilla extract, cinnamon, powdered sugar, and sea salt into your blender or food processor. Pulse to combine and then blend on high until the mixture turns into a luscious, smooth paste. This usually takes about 2-3 minutes. Don’t rush—scrape down the sides if needed to make sure everything blends evenly.

Step 3: Adjust Consistency and Taste

If your spread feels thicker than you like, add a little more milk by the teaspoon until it reaches perfect spreadable consistency. Give it a quick taste and add more cinnamon or powdered sugar to suit your preferences. This is your moment to make it exactly how you want.

Step 4: Enjoy or Store

The cookie butter is ready to enjoy right away—spread it on toast, swirl it into oatmeal, or just eat it by the spoonful (no judgment here!). If you’re saving for later, transfer to an airtight jar and pop it in the fridge.

How to Serve Homemade Cookie Butter Spread Recipe

Garnishes

I love topping my cookie butter with a light sprinkle of crushed gingersnap crumbs or a dash of cinnamon for an extra-special touch. Sometimes I add a few mini chocolate chips or chopped nuts on top—it makes the jar look pretty and adds some delightful crunch.

Side Dishes

This spread is fantastic alongside warm toast, fresh fruit slices like apples or pears, or swirled into yogurt or oatmeal for a comforting breakfast. My kids adore it slathered on pancakes, too.

Creative Ways to Present

For gifts or parties, I like to layer cookie butter in small jars with crushed cookie pieces or drizzle a bit of melted chocolate over the top before sealing. Presenting it with a cute spreader and a personalized tag never fails to impress friends and family.

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

I store leftover cookie butter in a glass jar with a tight lid in the fridge. It keeps well for up to two weeks, and just a quick stir before using brings back that perfect creamy texture.

Freezing

Freezing cookie butter isn’t something I do often because it’s so quick to make, but if you want to stash some away, freeze it in an airtight container. When thawed in the fridge overnight, it may separate slightly, but a good stir will fix it right up.

Reheating

If your cookie butter firms up in the fridge, I just let it sit at room temperature for 15-20 minutes or warm it gently by placing the jar in warm water before stirring. Avoid microwaving directly as it can change the texture.

FAQs

Final Thoughts

This Homemade Cookie Butter Spread Recipe quickly became one of my all-time favorites—simple ingredients come together to create something surprisingly special. Whether you’re spreading it on toast, baking with it, or just indulging straight from the jar, I promise you’ll love this little jar of happiness. Give it a try, tweak it to your liking, and let me know how your batch turns out!

Print